Local costs · New York

What it costs to own a home in Cayuga County, New York

The real property-tax rate, risk-adjusted insurance, and honest closing costs for Cayuga County — with the all-in monthly cost of the area’s median-priced home and the income it takes to carry it comfortably.

The headline numbers

Property tax rate2.19%of home value per year · above the New York average 1.96% · national 0.92%
US Census, ACS 2024 5-year
Home insurance$1,330/yrrange $860–$1,930 at the New York median home value · county risk-adjusted
Closing costs$8,700–$14,400buyer’s estimate on the $449,800 median home
All-in monthly$3,838/momedian home, 20% down, 6.43% 30-yr rate (as of 2026-07-02)
A household income of about $221,552 makes the $449,800 median home here comfortable by our math — housing under about 28% of take-home pay with room left over for everyday spending. How we compute this.

Run these numbers with your income →

The “median home” here is the New York statewide median owner-occupied value ($449,800, US Census ACS 2024 1-year) — no county-level median is available in our data, so it is labeled as a state figure. The all-in monthly uses the real-life basis: loan payment $2,258, property tax $820, insurance $111, maintenance $375 (1%/yr rule of thumb), and utilities $275 (a placeholder, not yet sourced). With 20% down there is no mortgage insurance.

Local risk flags

No natural-hazard flags for Cayuga County in the FEMA National Risk Index — no covered peril rates Relatively High or Very High here. That does not mean zero risk; check the specific address’s flood zone before you buy.

Closing costs, in detail

Total transfer/recording tax $1,799: buyer's customary share $0, seller's customary share $1,799. NY state transfer tax: $1,799 (seller-paid). NYC levies an additional city RPTT (see borough adders); Yonkers and Mt. Vernon also levy city taxes.

Transfer & recording tax
On the $449,800 median home, the buyer’s customary share is about $0, with roughly $1,799 customarily paid by the seller. Only the buyer’s share is counted in the closing-cost estimate above.
Title insurance & settlement
New York uses competitive (filed) rates. Estimated $2,294–$3,104 on this home. Modeled title insurance + settlement (national declining-rate curve, ~0.60% of price at this level). Not a state-promulgated rate.
Lender and origination
$1,799–$3,598. Modeled as 0.5-1.0% of loan amount.
Appraisal, inspection, and reports
$900–$1,800. Flat buyer-paid diligence estimate.
Prepaids and escrow
$3,612–$5,473. Initial escrow deposit for taxes and insurance.

Frequently asked

What is the property tax rate in Cayuga County, NY?
The effective property tax rate in Cayuga County is 2.19% of home value per year (US Census, ACS 2024 5-year). That is higher than the New York average of 1.96% and higher than the national average of 0.92%.
How much is homeowners insurance in Cayuga County?
A typical homeowners policy runs about $1,330 per year (range $860–$1,930) at the New York median home value of $449,800. This is a county-adjusted estimate scaled from the NAIC state average; a real quote depends on the home and coverage.
What are typical closing costs on a $449,800 home in Cayuga County?
Estimated buyer closing costs run about $8,705–$14,375 on a $449,800 home — lender fees, title and settlement, the buyer's customary share of transfer and recording taxes, and prepaid taxes and insurance.
What income do you need to afford the median home in Cayuga County?
A household income of about $221,552 per year makes the $449,800 median home here comfortable by our math — housing under about 28% of take-home pay with room left for everyday spending, assuming 20% down at this week's 6.43% 30-year rate.
What is the all-in monthly cost of the median home in Cayuga County?
About $3,838 per month for the $449,800 median home with 20% down at 6.43% — the loan payment, property tax, home insurance, maintenance, and an estimated utilities figure.

Run your own numbers

These figures use the area median and a 20%-down example. Put in your own price, down payment, income, and debts to see whether it’s comfortable for you.

Open the calculator for Cayuga County

More counties in New York

Albany CountyAllegany CountyBronx CountyBroome CountyCattaraugus CountyChautauqua CountyChemung CountyChenango CountyAll 62 counties →

Sources & vintages

  • Property tax: US Census American Community Survey, county effective rate (ACS 2024 5-year).
  • Home insurance: NAIC state average premium (2022 · FEMA NRI December 2025), scaled by FEMA National Risk Index covered-peril risk; range modeled.
  • Median home value: US Census, New York statewide median owner-occupied value (ACS 2024 1-year) — used as a state-level stand-in for a county median.
  • Mortgage rate: Freddie Mac 30-year fixed weekly average via FRED, as of 2026-07-02.
  • Transfer taxes & title: researched state/local schedules; utilities and the household baseline are labeled placeholders.

Estimates, not advice, and not a Loan Estimate. Every number is computed from public data or our own math — see the methodology for how, and where the honest gaps are.