Local costs · New York
What it costs to own a home in Erie County, New York
The real property-tax rate, risk-adjusted insurance, and honest closing costs for Erie County — with the all-in monthly cost of a county-median-priced home and the income it takes to carry it comfortably.
The headline numbers
US Census, ACS 2024 5-year
Run these numbers with your income →
The “median home” here is the Erie County median owner-occupied value ($233,800, US Census ACS B25077, ACS 2024 5-year). The all-in monthly uses the real-life basis: loan payment $1,203, property tax $385, insurance $78, maintenance $195 (1%/yr rule of thumb), and utilities $275 (a placeholder, not yet sourced). With 20% down there is no mortgage insurance.
Local risk flags
From the FEMA National Risk Index (December 2025). Covered perils show up as insurance-premium pressure; flood and earthquake are called out because a standard policy excludes them.
Severe winter-storm risk in this county can push premiums above the state average.
Elevated tornado risk here can nudge premiums above the state average.
Notable flood risk — standard policies don't cover flood; check the address's flood zone and consider a separate policy.
Closing costs, in detail
Total transfer/recording tax $935: buyer's customary share $0, seller's customary share $935. NY state transfer tax: $935 (seller-paid). NYC levies an additional city RPTT (see borough adders); Yonkers and Mt. Vernon also levy city taxes.
- Transfer & recording tax
- On the $233,800 median home, the buyer’s customary share is about $0, with roughly $935 customarily paid by the seller. Only the buyer’s share is counted in the closing-cost estimate above.
- Title insurance & settlement
- New York uses competitive (filed) rates. Estimated $1,529–$2,069 on this home. Modeled title insurance + settlement (national declining-rate curve, ~0.77% of price at this level). Not a state-promulgated rate.
- Lender and origination
- $935–$1,870. Modeled as 0.5-1.0% of loan amount.
- Appraisal, inspection, and reports
- $900–$1,800. Flat buyer-paid diligence estimate.
- Prepaids and escrow
- $1,773–$2,699. Initial escrow deposit for taxes and insurance.
Frequently asked
- What is the property tax rate in Erie County, NY?
- The effective property tax rate in Erie County is 1.98% of home value per year (US Census, ACS 2024 5-year). That is about the same as the New York average of 1.96% and higher than the national average of 0.92%.
- How much is homeowners insurance in Erie County?
- A typical homeowners policy runs about $930 per year (range $610–$1,340) at the Erie County median home value of $233,800. This is a county-adjusted estimate scaled from the NAIC state average; a real quote depends on the home and coverage.
- What are typical closing costs on a $233,800 home in Erie County?
- Estimated buyer closing costs run about $5,237–$8,838 on a $233,800 home — lender fees, title and settlement, the buyer's customary share of transfer and recording taxes, and prepaid taxes and insurance.
- What income do you need to afford the median home in Erie County?
- A household income of about $115,843 per year makes the $233,800 median home here comfortable by our math — housing under about 28% of take-home pay with room left for everyday spending, assuming 20% down at this week's 6.67% 30-year rate.
- What is the all-in monthly cost of the median home in Erie County?
- About $2,136 per month for the $233,800 median home with 20% down at 6.67% — the loan payment, property tax, home insurance, maintenance, and an estimated utilities figure.
Run your own numbers
These figures use the area median and a 20%-down example. Put in your own price, down payment, income, and debts to see whether it’s comfortable for you.
Open the calculator for Erie CountyMore counties in New York
Sources & vintages
- Property tax: US Census American Community Survey, county effective rate (ACS 2024 5-year).
- Home insurance: NAIC state average premium (2022 · FEMA NRI December 2025), scaled by FEMA National Risk Index covered-peril risk; range modeled.
- Median home value: US Census ACS B25077, Erie County median owner-occupied value (ACS 2024 5-year).
- Mortgage rate: Freddie Mac 30-year fixed weekly average via FRED, as of 2026-08-13.
- Transfer taxes & title: researched state/local schedules. The everyday-spending baseline ships from the BLS Consumer Expenditure Survey (2024), income-scaled; utilities is the one remaining labeled placeholder.
Estimates, not advice, and not a Loan Estimate. Every number is computed from public data or our own math — see the methodology for how, and where the honest gaps are.